“The Straits of Hormuz are open. There’s almost as much oil flowing out now as there was before this conflict began.”
Secretary of State Marco Rubio, Athens, October 7
The White House has asked the Pentagon for Iran strike options that could be carried out before the November 3 midterms, The Atlantic reported Wednesday, citing two administration officials. By Thursday morning Brent crude was up more than 4%, trading near $104.59 a barrel against Wednesday’s $100.20 settle.
Read the report all the way through and the pitch undoes itself. The officials who back limited strikes concede the strikes would not, on their own, do any of these three things:
- Bring Iran back to the negotiating table.
- Restore safe passage through the Strait of Hormuz, which Rubio told reporters in Athens was already open.
- Lower gasoline prices before Election Day.
So you are looking at a plan that its own supporters say will not cut your fuel bill, in a week when its first measurable effect was a higher oil price.
What a $4 Barrel Means at Your Pump
Walk it through. A barrel holds 42 gallons. Brent’s $4.39 jump works out to roughly 10 cents a gallon if it holds and refiners pass it along. That lands on a national average AAA put at $4.41 on October 1, coming off a September that averaged $4.33, the highest September on record. Pump prices trail crude by days to weeks. There are 26 days left before the vote.
Thursday’s move had more than one cause, and it is worth separating them:
- The strike-options report, with US Central Command drawing up plans and no final decision made.
- Houthi missile attacks that killed three people at airports in Riyadh and Abha, plus a tanker attacked deep in the Persian Gulf for the first time in weeks.
- A hurricane that forced some US production offline.
Only the first of those is a choice somebody in Washington is making. You have seen how this market handles the real thing: when US strikes hit Iran in June, Wall Street slid and oil whipsawed near $88.
Here is where BTN stands. Timing a military option to an election calendar is a campaign decision, and drivers are already being billed for it. The tell is the argument inside the building. The Atlantic’s sources say some of the president’s advisers would rather wait until after the vote, worried that renewed fighting, especially American deaths, would hurt Republican candidates. The war is in its eighth month and has already killed 19 US troops. That is a debate about the midterms. It is not a debate about Hormuz.
And the administration cannot hold both of its own positions. If Rubio is right that the strait is open, there is no oil case for bombing before November. If the strike backers are right that it is not safe, the secretary of state is describing a calm that tankers in the Gulf are not seeing. Either way, the cheaper-gas rationale fails on the administration’s own words.
The White House had not responded publicly to the report by Thursday morning. Every day it stays silent, the risk premium stays in the price of your next fill-up.